How The Senate Filibuster Reform Fight Saved Elizabeth Warren’s Consumer Board

by Sabrina Siddiqui and Ryan Grim
Huffington Post
 Posted: 07/17/2013 7:30 am EDT

 Democratic National Convention: Day 2

WASHINGTON — On Dec. 8, 2011, Senate Republicans blocked the confirmation of Richard Cordray, President Barack Obama’s nominee to head his signature consumer watchdog agency. Cordray had 53 votes in his favor. But Republicans were filibustering, meaning Democrats needed 60 votes to break it.

The problem, Republicans said, was not with Cordray, a former Ohio attorney general, but with the structure of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. They vowed to block any nominee unless significant structural changes made the consumer bureau more accountable to Congress. The GOP’s demands included putting in place a five-member board rather than a single director, and a requirement that the agency’s budget be approved through the appropriations process, which would have allowed Republicans to defund it.

On Tuesday morning, 71 senators voted to move forward on Cordray’s confirmation, including 17 Republicans. Later in the day, Cordray was confirmed by a vote of 66-34. None of the GOP demands had been met.

So what changed? The politics around the filibuster.

In exchange for not going nuclear in the Senate — changing the rules for approving presidential nominees — Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) won Cordray and six other Obama nominations related to environmental, labor and consumer issues.

Reid was, for Reid, jubilant. When he spotted a HuffPost reporter in his office Tuesday afternoon, he joked, “I haven’t had a chance to tell you about it, but I have a helluva good story on Romney’s tax returns that nobody has,” referencing a previous interview he’d given.

Obama called Reid Tuesday to congratulate him, and had earlier called a handful of Democrats who had been reluctant to support the nuclear option, including Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.). For all the celebration at both ends of Pennsylvania Avenue, a handful of junior members of the Senate made the Democratic victory possible.

Reid acknowledged as much Tuesday by sharing his weekly press conference with progressive Sens. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) and Tom Udall (D-N.M.), two outspoken advocates of filibuster reform whose fight to improve Senate functionality dates to early 2009.

The image of the three men standing together was a far cry from January, when Reid brokered a modest rules change with Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) that left the likes of Merkley and Udall dissatisfied. In that fight, Merkley, backed by a coalition of more than 70 progressive and labor organizations, spearheaded a proposal with far-reaching consequences (it would have ended the silent filibuster) and pushed for Reid to use the nuclear option.

The resulting dynamic between the two Democrats at times grew tense, with Reid once scolding Merkley for urging donors to pressure members of their caucus who were reluctant to go nuclear. But even though he didn’t adopt the demands of his more progressive members, Reid came to agree with them as the GOP obstruction continued immediately after the January deal.

Republicans mounted filibusters on three of Obama’s cabinet nominees — Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel, CIA director John Brennan, and EPA nominee Gina McCarthy. Hagel and Brennan were later confirmed, but not without drama and delay. McCarthy’s fate hung in the balance until this week. The obstructionism climaxed when Republicans continued to block Caitlin Halligan, Obama’s pick to serve on the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, forcing the president to withdraw the nomination.

This time, rather than battling, Reid and Merkley were working from the same script. Labor unions, which had waged an expensive campaign last winter to pressure Democrats to reform the filibuster, stayed mostly quiet this time around, as Reid appeared genuinely invested.

Click Here to continue reading.

Enhanced by Zemanta
This entry was posted in Financial/economic information, Illuminati/Terrorism/Corruption, Political and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to How The Senate Filibuster Reform Fight Saved Elizabeth Warren’s Consumer Board

  1. Pingback: Major Victory in Fight Against GOP Obstruction and… | Sunset Daily

  2. DrinkDeep says:

    This is a crock – name one Productive thing that the CFPB has accomplished, aside from spending mountains of money? I received a credit card application recently that offered:
    $300 total credit limit
    $245 immediately billed as charges and fees for getting the card
    39% interest rate (!!!!!)
    As best I can tell, the CFPB’s only input here was that they used a font large enough to read

    I’m surprised that Merkley came right out and used the P word (Progressive) – not a real popular phrase in Oregon, land of retirees. While I appreciate the guy for voting against the NDAA, I sure have a hard time figuring out what he has actually accomplished? He’s up for re-election in 2014, so I guess we’ll be hearing plenty about his “accomplishments”.

    I expect most of the senators up for re-election will be working hard to associate themselves with Elizabeth Warren as she’s so popular. I hope they’re All voted out – but if my ‘fantasy cabinet’ ever comes together, Warren will be Treasury Secretary 😉

    • Jean says:

      DD, I think there is a lot you may not yet ‘get’. Dunno, though, for sure. The CFPB was Elizabeth Warren’s ‘baby’, and the GOP wouldn’t give her one single inch!! In fact, they forced her out, and she didn’t give up: she came back, much to their chagrin I’ll bet, as a Senator. Now, she’s fighting for the CFPB once again, as well as for Glass-Steagall! I think she’s having a lot more success than people realize because the MSM also won’t give her an inch! This is a lady, who IMO doesn’t quit. It’s taken several years, but she’s gotten someone in there who is capable of doing the job. When this whole thing comes down, as I believe it’s about to do, we’ll have someone in there who works for us – not the cabal!

      Sometimes, it takes years to accomplish things. They don’t happen overnight 🙂

      Hugs, ~Jean

  3. BH says:

    Thought this may be of interest, in relation to this story. Received this via email from Sen. Jeff Merkley yesterday evening …

    Bryan –

    We did it: Today the Senate set aside the endless filibusters of Presidential nominees.

    Today’s votes to end these filibusters are a big victory for our progressive agenda and for protecting the middle class and America’s working families.

    By moving forward on these nominees, we will put a cop on the beat protecting families from predatory financial practices, strengthen the fight against global climate change, and protect our middle class and working families from workplace abuses.

    Some special interests still want to paralyze the Senate with further abuse of the silent filibuster. They want to obstruct our progressive agenda at every turn, abusing the filibuster to escape accountability and protect sweetheart deals at our expense.

    Thanks to today’s agreement, we’ll allow important agencies to do the people’s business. But if it turns out to be a one-day truce, then I won’t hesitate to pick up the torch again to end filibusters on the President’s nominees. And regardless, we need to keep up the fight to fix the way the Senate works on bills and judicial nominations.

    [Donation Request omitted]


    Senator Jeff Merkley

    I’m not much into politics, really, but I believe there is great importance in the work of Senator Merkley and Senator Warren, in the greater scheme of things that are happening.

    Much love!

    ~ bryan

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s